Federal’s pitch to the court starts with a paperwork problem. The insurer says it issued a Comprehensive General Liability policy to the Marianists Society Inc. running “From August 1, 1969 To Until Cancelled,” cancelled effective August 1, 1979, and an Umbrella Excess Liability policy covering Marianist of Ohio, Inc. and Marianists Society Inc. from September 1, 1973 to August 1, 1974. But Federal can only find declaration pages, endorsements and other policy fragments – not the full policies. The Marianist Province, the complaint says, has not produced complete copies either.
